Technically Speaking, October 2023

Hello readers, and welcome to another edition of Technically Speaking!

If you have been checking your inbox regularly, then you’ve probably noticed more in-person meetings popping up around you. Months of planning and execution are now bearing fruit as more and more members join the in-person events and get back to the normal that we knew of, pre-COVID. 

At this point, I’d like to share my story with you. 

I completed my CMT examinations in 2016 and worked with a prop firm in Hyderabad, India. My CMT emails went unopened, moving to older pages in my inbox as I continued to wait for amazing things to happen to me after the completion of the Level III examination. While I was extremely happy and proud of myself for completing the three levels, I assumed that efforts were limited to those landmarks. Aside from a couple of events here and there, I could have done more to interact actively with members of the CMT community. 

This was the mistake I was making. 

My initiative lost steam once I achieved my big goal of studying and passing the exams. Only in 2019, when I met Joel Pannikot at the Hyderabad CMT Chapter meet, did I take the initiative to be more involved with the association. Credit to Joel’s foresight, identifying the roles we could play as volunteers was the first step of getting our foot in the door. My volunteer journey began with building an India-specific newsletter as an individual entity. This may not seem like the biggest project one could take on. Still, the newsletter led to multiple fruitful conversations with reputed analysts all over India, and suddenly, I had access to them. Eventually, this grew into me taking responsibility for the global newsletter, including numerous opportunities to present at the CMT symposiums, associating with global leaders, and interacting with the best minds in the business. For that matter, my voluntary initiatives with the CMT Association led to an excellent work opportunity with JC Parets and the Allstarcharts team! 

So is this an exclusive club, where you benefit only when you’re a more significant part of it? Absolutely not. Getting involved with the association merely translates to global exposure and, subsequently, easy access to folks worldwide! 

So, what is the point of this story? 

Don’t wait for things to happen for you. If you are interested, take the first step and participate in a local chapter meeting. If the chapter meeting is yet to occur in your region, reach out to someone nearest to you. I cannot stress enough how important it is to put in the time to build relationships. And if you thought there were only a couple of ways to interact with the CMT Association, think again. This link could lead to innumerable outcomes, but you must drive it. 

If you’re looking for an example, here’s yours truly! 

Until next time, think technical!

Rashmi Bhatnagar 

Editor

What's Inside...

President's Letter

The third quarter ended on a busy note for the CMT Association. Here are a few highlights:

  • Many CMT...
Read More

Congratulations Charterholders

Congratulations to the CMT charterholders who were named in the 2023 Institutional Investor All-American Ranking for Technical Analysis. Three of...

Read More

S&P 500 Buy Signal Triggered

The Bull or Bear debate rages on. And with September 2023’s monthly close punctuating the end of the 3rd quarter,...

Read More

US Rates and Equities: Long Term Trend Reversals and Price Targets

 

Over the past month the 10-year US Treasury yield has rallied to a high of...

Read More

A Transcontinental Odyssey: Unveiling Financial Landscapes from India to the UAE

A few months ago, Tyler, Kaizad and I talked about...

Read More

President's Letter

The third quarter ended on a busy note for the CMT Association. Here are a few highlights:

  • Many CMT charter-holders descended on Las Vegas for the third annual FX Evolution conference (hat tip Tyrone Abela) for three days of networking and education in late September.

 

  • The August 2023 Investment Challenge, which is an integral part of the Academic Partner Program, was an immense success. Congratulations to our individual and institutional winners; and gracious thanks to our CMT charter-holder mentors who supported these participants. Without your volunteerism, we would not be training the next generation of traders, portfolio managers, and future CMT charter-holders!

 

  • Chapter meetings in Puget Sound, Chicago, and Chennai were carried out successfully. We look forward to hearing about other chapters’ events in the coming months!

 

I would like to take the remainder of the letter to direct your attention to one of the CMT Association’s flagship educational publications, Fill The Gap: The Official Podcast of the CMT Association. Created and produced by two of the most dedicated and ardent believers in the field of trend-following (David Lundgren and Tyler Wood), Fill the Gap has released thirty-two episodes since January 2021 with a new episode dropping each month. The interviewed guests are quite unique, ranging from long-only equity PMs to long-short equity PMs, to fixed income traders, to even crypto-currency specialists, that there should be plenty of cross-asset knowledge to glean from each episode. More importantly, Dave and Tyler have made a habit of interviewing dual charter-holders (CFA, CMT) that have generally began their investing careers from a fundamental standpoint (acquiring the CFA charter) but have realized that additional technical factors, such as market timing, trend determination, and momentum investing could be additive inputs into their investment framework and thus acquired the CMT designation. I have picked up myriad tidbits from these interviews, whether it be entrepreneurial experience in Episode 31 with former Board colleague Clint Sorenson, cryptocurrency education in Episode 30 with another former Board colleague Jamie Coutts, or even this macro trader learning about the world of equity investing from our many guests. There will be many more conversations between Dave and Tyler with their guests in the coming months, but I urge you all to give it a listen, then give us your feedback, and spread the word to your teammates! We need more CMTs!

Happy Trading, Be Flexible.

Rob Palladino

President

Contributor(s)

Robert Palladino, CMT

Robert Palladino, who holds a Chartered Market Technician (CMT) designation, is a senior foreign exchange trader for JPMorgan Chase with experience trading foreign exchange, commodities, and interest rate products, including derivatives. His foreign exchange career has allowed him to work in Hong...

Congratulations Charterholders

Congratulations to the CMT charterholders who were named in the 2023 Institutional Investor All-American Ranking for Technical Analysis. Three of the top four spots went to CMT chartherholders

Rank Analyst Firm
1 Rich Ross, CMT Evercore ISI
2 Christopher Verrone, CMT Strategas Research
4 Craig Johnson, CMT, CFA Piper Sandler

 

They have achieved notable recognition within the industry for their exceptional contributions and achievements. The recognition is a testament to their dedication to excellence in the use of Technical Analysis to add value for their clients.

We are immensely proud of them for their remarkable achievements. Their dedication to pushing the boundaries in our industry and their commitment to delivering outstanding results have not only earned them this prestigious recognition but have also contributed significantly to the application of Technical Analysis in security selection and portfolio management.

We also extend our congratulations to the following CMT charterholders who also received II votes and recognition in Technical Analysis:

Analyst Firm
Jeff DeGraaf, CMT, CFA Renaissance Macro Research
Stephen Suttmeier, CMT, CFA BofA Securities
Jonathan Krinsky, CMT BTIG
Mark Newton, CMT Fundstrat Global Advisors
Ari Wald, CMT, CFA Oppenheimer & Co.
Kevin Dempter, CMT Renaissance Macro Research
Paul Ciana, CMT BofA Securities
JC O’Hara, CMT Roth MKM
George Davis, CMT RBC
Dan Wantrobski, CMT Janney Montgomery Scott
Russ Visch, CMT BMO Capital Markets
Sid Mokhtari, CMT CIBC World Markets
John Kolovos, CMT Macro Risk Advisors
Pat Tschosik, CMT, CFA Ned Davis Research
Tim Hayes, CMT Ned Davis Research
David Nicoski, CMT Vermilion Technical Research
Javed Mirza, CMT, CFA Canaccord Genuity

 

Their contributions extend beyond their individual accomplishments; they embody the collaborative spirit and commitment to excellence that defines CMT Association and the CMT charter.

Alvin Kressler

CEO, CMT Association

Contributor(s)

Alvin Kressler

Alvin Kressler is Executive Director & CEO of the CMT Association. Alvin was previously Director of Research and Corporate Access at Bloomberg Tradebook.  Before joining Bloomberg, he was the Executive Director of The New York Society of Security Analysts (NYSSA). At over...

S&P 500 Buy Signal Triggered

The Bull or Bear debate rages on. And with September 2023’s monthly close punctuating the end of the 3rd quarter, the S&P 500’s momentum is signaling a historically reliable buy signal which has been profitable in both secular bull and bear markets.

 

THE CHARTS

Chart 1 below shows the S&P 500’s monthly candles and a 12/48 price oscillator.1 This momentum indicator divides a 12-month moving average by a 48-month moving average. 12 measures one year and 48 measures the trend of an average business cycle lasting roughly 4 years.2 Buy signals occur when the 12/48 Oscillator crosses above its 9-period moving average as pointed out on the chart with upward facing green arrows. Our strategy buys the following month’s open, holds for 12-months as shown with the grey shading, and finally, as pointed out with downward facing red arrows, sells at the open of the 13th month.

 

Chart 1 below starts with most of the secular bull market following the end of World-War II through the Go-Go Years of the 60s. The black horizontal line marks the secular bear of the 70s and early 80s. Chart 1 ends just after the ‘87 crash/Black Monday, just a few years into the secular bull which raged until the 2000 Dot-Com Bust.

 

 

Chart 2 below picks up where Chart 1 left off. It starts with the remaining decade-plus secular bull following the ‘87 crash. The black horizontal line marks the secular bear of the 2000’s, and the subsequent secular bull market through the Covid Crash and 2022. It is current through last month, labeled with a green arrow and marked Latest Signal, 09/2023. These two charts spotlight all 21 signals since the early 1950s, and the rightmost green arrow on Chart 2 shows us September’s 22nd signal.

 

 

THE DETAILS

Since the early 1950s, this signal has triggered 21 times with September 2023 being the 22nd. Table 1 below uses upward facing green bars and downward facing red bars to illustrate the total percentage change over the 12-month holding periods for all 21 prior signals. The red circles show the maximum drawdown during those holds. Some observations:

 

  • 19 signals closed higher after 12 months, while only 2 closed lower.
  • 13 of the 21 signals, roughly 62%, had a maximum drawdown from entry of less than 5%.
  • Signal 21 in 2019 had the largest maximum drawdown of almost 35%, but still closed higher by more than 15% after 12-months.
  • The 2 losing signals were numbers 4 of 1965 and 17 of 2007. They both finished with losses between -8.5 to -almost 13% after being down between almost 18 to 21%.

 

 

Table 2 below fills in the details listing all 21 prior signals. Some interesting statistics:

 

  • The 12/48 Oscillator is averaging 3 to 4 buy signals a decade.
  • The win-rate for all signals is almost 90.5%, with 19 of 21 signals closing higher after 12 months.
  • The median gain is almost 10%, while the median drawdown is about -4.25%.
  • The largest gain is more than 32%, while the largest loss is roughly -13% which was signal 4 in ‘65.
  • The largest drawdown was almost -32.5% after the 2019 signal, number 21, which still managed to close with a gain of more than 16% 12 months later.
  • 15 signals triggered during secular bulls and 6 during secular bears.
  • Of the two losses, signal 4 occurred during a secular bull and signal 17 during a secular bear.
  • 5 of 6 signals, 83%, during secular bears were profitable. Notable gains include 17.27% after signal 7 in 1975 and almost 12.75% after signal 18 in 2009.
  • Skew and Excess Kurtosis calculations explain that the distribution of returns is close to a normal distribution, increasing the believability of the statistical significance.

 

 

CONCLUSION

In addition to having a remarkable winning record, an interesting attribute of this signal is how effective it is irrespective of the secular trend. This adds to the timeliness of the current signal. Despite having never seen another technician watching a monthly 12/48 price oscillator, there is an identifiable pattern. Perhaps it is the importance of the 12 and 48-month periods, or perhaps it is due to our human inclination to find patterns amongst the randomness. As part of a trading system or market call, secular bull or secular bear, historically following this signal there has been a 90+% chance that price will be higher 12-months from now. If not, September’s signal will become only the 3rd failed signal of 22 instances spanning the last 65+ years of market history.

 

REFERENCES

  1. Pring, M. J. (2014). In Technical Analysis Explained (Fifth Edition, p. 292-296). McGraw-Hill Education.
  2. Ibid, (p. 19).

Contributor(s)

Louis Spector, CMT

Louis J. Spector, is an analytical thinker. He enjoys pursuing ambitious goals through dedication, continuing education, and a positive mental attitude. Louis currently works for a boutique wealth management firm in Bergen County New Jersey as the Chief Technical Strategist. There he...

US Rates and Equities: Long Term Trend Reversals and Price Targets

 

Over the past month the 10-year US Treasury yield has rallied to a high of more than 4.8%. 

These are the highest levels seen since 2007 and are creating what looks like a potential long term

headwind for the S&P 500 and US equity returns.  Simply put, bond yields have a major impact on the cost of capital in valuing equities.

As bond yields push higher, the future cash flows for equities will continue to get discounted at higher rates.
In addition, US Treasuries yielding 5% provide an enticing risk free alternative to equities.

Overtime, in the current “higher for longer” environment, equity valuations will compress and prices will fall.

 

For a visual on the current relationship between the 10-year yield and the S&P 500 I have pulled the chart below (Chart A).

As you can see, in September of 1981 yields were peaking at close to 16% and equity markets were flat.

As yields began to fade and enter a Secular Bear Market, the S&P 500 (acting inversely) entered a multi-decade Secular Bull Market.
In December of 2021 the S&P 500 peaked with the 10-year at ~1.50%.

The absolute spread at that point between the S&P500 and the 10-year yield hit a high of  4766. 

This spread is currently ~4250 representing a level that is still over 3 standard deviations from the mean for the time period 1962 through today.

Clearly, even with the recent massive surge in yield, there is a need for additional reversion to bring this spread back inline.  

 

Chart A

Source: Bloomberg

 

The question is how does that happen?  What does that look like?

In a real effort to simplify that answer I have pulled the two charts below.

Ignore all the rhetoric.  Just for a moment forget Mr. Powell, Spreads, Economic Releases, Forward P/E Ratios, Dot Plots, Geopolitics, etc.

Chart B below shows the 10-Year Yield from 1970 through today.

This includes a massive Secular Bear Market which extended from 1981 through 2020.

That downtrend line has been broken, yields have hit their lows and a new Bull Market has begun.

I am marking the upside target for yields at 6.4% based on a Fibonacci Retracement for the entire peak-to-trough move highlighted below.

 

Chart B

Source: Bloomberg

 

Chart C below shows the S&P 500 from 1970 through today.

This includes a massive Secular Bull Market which extended from 1980 through 2021.

That uptrend line has yet to be tested or broken, leaving real room for a significant move to the downside.

I am marking the downside target for the S&P 500 at 3000 based on a Fibonacci Retracement for the entire trough-to-peak move highlighted below.

 

Chart C

Source: Bloomberg

 

In conclusion, markets in general are volatile and misaligned.  We function in a continuous state of information overload.

Simple, objective Technical Analysis eliminates the noise which is more often than not just that, noise.

There is ~35% upside in US 10-Year Yields (target 6.40%) which I believe will coincide with a ~30% move to the downside in the S&P 500 (target 3000).

Contributor(s)

Anthony F. Esposito, CMT

Anthony Esposito is a Director of US Equities at ScotiaBank in NY. He was an NYSE Floor Broker, Buy-Side Trader/Analyst for a large Single Family Office, and Risk Trader. He has completed the distinguished Chartered Market Technician Program, receiving the CMT designation,...

A Transcontinental Odyssey: Unveiling Financial Landscapes from India to the UAE

A few months ago, Tyler, Kaizad and I talked about the importance of engaging in person with the financial services industry across the Asia Pacific region. The Asia Roadshow I embarked on this July reminded me how important it is for us to kickstart the community experience in the CMT-sphere so we can achieve our mission.

Prelude: Trichy and Chennai

Before our odyssey began, Trichy and Chennai served as the opening act. I visited some top academic institutions there including IIM Trichy and IIT Madras, in addition to NSE Academy. Known for academic brilliance, these cities are emerging hubs for financial studies and market research, laying fertile ground for the advancement of technical analysis.

The Indian Chapter

Delhi: The Policy Hub (Day 1)

Tyler met with us on his birthday. In Delhi, the seat of India’s government, policy and regulation often drive market trends. This city acts as a crucible where political decisions influence financial strategies, offering a unique vantage point on the complex relationship between governance and markets.

We managed to meet with top buyside investment and research houses and stellar academic institutions. We also addressed a meeting organised by ANMI (the broker’s association in India) where Tyler spoke of the value of technical analysis for brokers, and I underscored the importance of understanding behavioural psychology in the investment process.

Bengaluru: Silicon Valley of India (Day 2)

Bengaluru is India’s tech haven where startups bloom like spring flowers. Often seen as the technology backbone of India’s financial markets, this city represents the confluence of innovation and investment.

We got to meet our academic partners, and exciting fintech-enabled broking houses before ending the day with a delightful meeting and dinner with our members.

Mumbai: India’s Financial Colossus (Days 3-5)

Mumbai is India’s Wall Street, a buzzing hive of brokers, asset managers, and investors. The city stands as the country’s financial heart, beating to the rhythms of market highs and lows.

In 3 days in Mumbai, we were able to meet with officials in SEBI, NSE, top wealth managers, our academic partners, as well as to host knowledge sessions for our members and students.

The Road Ahead in India

Each Indian city lent its unique hue to our colourful tapestry of experiences, fortifying our optimism about CMT Association’s role in India’s evolving financial landscape.

 

The UAE Chapter

Abu Dhabi: The Regional Powerhouse (Day 1)

Abu Dhabi, the UAE’s political and industrial capital, serves as a cornerstone for regional financial policy. Its influence radiates across Middle Eastern markets, making it a key hub for investment and financial planning.

We spent a day in Abu Dhabi meeting with key regional influencers, Abu Dhabi Securities exchange, as well as a delightful meeting of members.

Dubai: The Financial Epicenter (Days 2-5)

Dubai is the UAE’s showstopper—a global city where East meets West. Known for its remarkable skyline, Dubai also has a towering presence in finance, featuring one of the world’s fastest-growing markets.

The next day we came to Dubai. 4 hectic days saw us attending a CISI continuing professional development event, getting our own members together for a member meet that evening (which was a joy), regulators, top brokers, exchanges, fund managers and family offices and more. Vishal Mehta, CMT, Member of the board, joined us to add his own unique perspective to this memorable journey.

The UAE Outlook

With its booming financial centers, the UAE serves as a dynamic extension to our India story, promising new avenues of collaboration and learning.

Conclusion

From the academic corridors of Trichy to the skyscraper-lined avenues of Dubai, our roadshow was a kaleidoscopic journey through the heartlands of financial innovation and market mechanics. As we strengthen our footprint in these diverse terrains, one thing remains abundantly clear: the road ahead is filled with opportunities for CMT Association to enrich and expand the discourse around technical analysis on a global scale.

Contributor(s)

Joel Pannikot

Joel Pannikot (pronounced as Punny-Quote) is the Managing Director of Chartered Market Technician Private Limited and serves as the Head of the Asia-Pacific region for the CMT Association. In this role, he is committed to advancing the field of technical analysis through...